SCENESSCENESSCENESSCENES
    0
  •   was successfully added to your cart.
  • Home
  • Country
  • Pop
  • Rock
  • Americana
  • R&B
  • Culture
  • Premium
  • About
  • Contact
    • Music Submissions
    • Advertising
      • Media Kit
    • Customer Support
  • Shop

The Resurrection of Gavin Stone: What’s Still Wrong With Christian Filmmaking

    Home Feature The Resurrection of Gavin Stone: What’s Still Wrong With Christian Filmmaking
    Resurrection of Gavin Stone

    The Resurrection of Gavin Stone: What’s Still Wrong With Christian Filmmaking

    By Matt Noble | Feature, Movie Review | 4 comments | 24 January, 2017 | 0

    I like walking into movies not really knowing what to expect. I avoid watching trailers when possible and any news or hype surrounding a movie.  I want my first experience of the film to be free of any presumptions or preconceptions. So, I only knew one thing about The Resurrection of Gavin Stone when news of its release started: it was a Christian film produced by a Church.

    I am going to put all my cards on the table. I strongly dislike Christian films, even though I claim Christianity as my faith. There are many reasons why and I’ll talk about a few in this review. However,  despite my prejudices, I give every film a chance, so I went into Gavin Stone with a sense of tabula rasa.

    First, the story (spoiler alert):

    Christian filmmaking has often struggled to create original and compelling stories, and Gavin Stone is no exception. It begins with the overused theme of a rough-around-the-edges, down-on-his-luck character (this time a former Hollywood child actor played by Brett Dalton) who has had nothing to do with religion his whole life. After some infraction with the law, he must now serve a court-ordered community service at a church in small-town Illinois.

    We all know he’s going to struggle with integrating into the community because he simply doesn’t share the Christian/spiritual beliefs that now surrounds him. However, as time goes on, and he is treated with love and grace, he’ll soften and realize this is exactly what he’s been looking for his whole life. That’s Gavin Stone in a nutshell.

    There’s no real character development to set up Gavin in Hollywood as a genuine person looking for real friends or purpose. There’s nothing about this church and its struggle to figure out how to reach out to a former child-star from the West Coast, and when Hollywood calls Gavin back, they just look like a bunch of evil jerks. Really?

    This simply proves that Christians still do not understand Hollywood. To them, it’s a place that encourages narcissism. A place where people are incapable of looking for meaningful and real relationships. And what of their obvious belief that Hollywood is filled with hateful unbelievers in second chances? That’s Gavin Stone‘s depiction of Hollywood, and it’s just too stereotypical to be considered

    I’ve met directors, producers, and writers in LA, and they are just as human and normal as everyone else. Some of them are nicer than Christians I’ve met. So what’s going on here? Well, as usual, Christian filmmakers like to set up a straw-man character to change with the gospel.

    They only have 90 minutes to give this person faith, so it has to be easy and complete. They begin with a character (Gavin Stone) who is shallow, too shallow. He comes into frame so full of himself that every situation is awkward. Real people don’t behave this way. Brett Dalton is capable of so much more range and realism, yet it apparently was never asked of him (nor, it would seem, of any his co-stars).

    Second, the other problems:

    Production quality continues to be a curse for Christian movies and I’m not sure why. Lyn Moncrief did cinematography for this film, and her past work is very beautiful, whether the movies were good or not. The editor, Kenneth Martsen, has helped on projects 50 times larger than this, and has plenty of incredible experience behind him. And yet, this movie is simply and inexplicable not pretty. For example, there is a shot of the Chicago skyline that looks like it was taken with an iPhone out of a plane window. There’s a shot of the church that was so clearly taken with a drone that it is painful. Oddly, this movie had the right people behind it to be beautiful, and it somehow is not. There’s no accounting for it.

    The dialogue in this film suffers greatly from a lack of realism and normalcy. It almost feels like a spoof of itself at moments. But it’s not fully self-aware and treats too many of its conversations and punchlines with seriousness. What results is a half-hearted comedy-spoof and fully earnest Christian movie. For instance, the movie makes fun of some weird stereotypical Christian catch-phrases, but then uses those very same phrase with all-too seriousness later on, which completely undermines the joke and the serious moment in one fell swoop. The script almost feels like something in between a compilation of “Babylon Bee” articles and God’s Not Dead. The question then becomes: does this make for a good film?

    Sadly, I cannot answer yes. If the point of Christian filmmaking is to enter the marketplace with industry competitive storytelling that conveys meaning and purpose in a beautiful way, through compelling acting, grounded screenwriting, and lovely cinematography, then it would appear that we are all still waiting for a Christian film to accomplish that. If the point, however, of Christian films is to make a fun, feel-good movie that tells an idealistic conversion story while satirizing our church idiosyncrasies, then we’ve got a winner.

    Now, if you’ve read all of this and thought that I am just playing the role of hateful critic, I assure you I am not. As I mentioned earlier I don’t like Christian films, even though I consider myself a Christian. The reason for that and this scathing review is this: I love film as an artistic storytelling method more than any other and I also believe that Christians have the greatest story to tell, one of redemption and sacrifice, suffering and loss, and beauty and love.

    So, if Christians insist on making films, they should make objectively good films for the marketplace with incredible storytelling that conveys beautiful meaning and purpose through compelling acting, good screenwriting, and gorgeous cinematography. Otherwise, the quality of your art may reflect poorly on the quality of your message.

    Christian Film, Christian Movie, Gavin Stone

    Matt Noble

    When not writing for Scenes, Matt enjoys visiting the National Parks with his wife, spending time with friends, and watching movies. He works full-time as a director of marketing for a publication company in Texas.

    More posts by Matt Noble

    Related Post

    • For Star Wars Fans, Does Solo Stir The Heart or Give Heartburn?

      By Chad Bonham | Comments are Closed

      The new standalone Star Wars tale endeavors to address key tenets of the human spirit with its focus on family and togetherness.

    • American Made

      Did Xenu Smuggle Cocaine for the Contras? Tom Cruise’s Fake History Movie, “American Made”

      By Jonathan Leaf | Comments are Closed

      “American Made” is to U.S. history what “Dumbo” is to elephant poaching. It’s lies piled on libel, smearing the names of Ronald Reagan and even Bill Clinton.

    • Brad's Status

      “Brad’s Status” Is a Winner

      By Jonathan Leaf | Comments are Closed

      How do we measure status and success? This funny, unsettling new Ben Stiller movie raises those uncomfortable questions. See it.

    • Prosperity

      “Prosperity” Is Rich In Ideas, But Perhaps Less In Answers

      By Jonathan Leaf | Comments are Closed

      The message of Prosperity is: Businesses need to look at profits and MORE. Are they good stewards of the planet? Are they ethical toward workers and customers?

    • Home Again

      “Home Again” Exiles Logic and Laughter

      By Jonathan Leaf | 1 comment

      Home Again is an intermittently watchable but idiotic movie for when you’re laid up in bed or recuperating in a hospital—or slightly drunk.

    • George Escobar August 11, 2017 at 11:40 am

      Matt, I respect your perspective and thoughts, but I think you may need to quality your statements under a basic premise of: “Compared to what?” Are you comparing films like ‘The Resurrection of Gavin Stone’ with other films from the independent film world of comparatively the same budget, experience level of the cast and crew, and (simiilar or opposing) worldviews? If so, then your comments have true merit. If not, if you are comparing your analysis to a Hollywood studio production, then you are not comparing ‘apples to apples’ but are instead making the classic mistake of comparing ‘apples to oranges.’ If you do an ‘apples-to-apples’ comparison, you’ll find that ‘The Resurrection of Gavin Stone’ actually fares well. Please, tell us your actual basis for comparison since your subhead says: …when compared with the standards of the industry.

    • George Escobar August 11, 2017 at 11:45 am

      CORRECTION: “qualify” your statements…, not “quality” in my previous posting.

    • George Escobar August 12, 2017 at 3:36 pm

      Movie critics make this “Hollywood industry standard” comparison mistake all the time. They compare ‘apples-to-oranges’ when they criticize Christian films (which often deserve criticism, but they should be done against their true indie film counterparts). You would never compare a ROLLS ROYCE or BENTLEY automobile against a Hyundai Elantra would you, and expect to have credibility with your comparison? So critics, please DO YOUR HOMEWORK first and make the proper comparison. It will take more work, but at least your criticism will be more accurate and helpful.

    • annes May 2, 2021 at 6:44 pm

      “I also believe that Christians have the greatest story to tell, one of redemption and sacrifice, suffering and loss, and beauty and love.” Matt Noble may want to see The Chosen, a new series (also directed by Dallas Jenkins), if he is into story telling.

    • Sign up for our Daily Digest, where we deliver the top headlines in music and exclusive SCENES Live Sessions details straight to your inbox!

    Download Sessions and Buy Merch

    • Brennley Brown on SCENES Live Sessions $2.99
    • Fellow Robot on SCENES Live Sessions $2.99
    • The Empty Pockets on SCENES Live Sessions $2.99
    • Tiera on SCENES Live Sessions $2.99
    • Raynes on SCENES Live Sessions $2.99
    • Media Kit
    • Privacy Policy
    © 2022 | All Rights Reserved
    • Home
    • Country
    • Pop
    • Rock
    • Americana
    • R&B
    • Culture
    • Premium
    • About
    • Contact
      • Music Submissions
      • Advertising
        • Media Kit
      • Customer Support
    • Shop
    SCENES
      0 items