SCENESSCENESSCENESSCENES
    0
  •   was successfully added to your cart.
  • Home
  • Country
  • Pop
  • Rock
  • Americana
  • R&B
  • Culture
  • Premium
  • About
  • Contact
    • Music Submissions
    • Advertising
      • Media Kit
    • Customer Support
  • Shop

The Joys of “Brooklyn”

    Home Hollywood Bush People The Joys of “Brooklyn”
    Brooklyn the Movie

    The Joys of “Brooklyn”

    By Harold Fickett | Hollywood Bush People, Movies | Comments are Closed | 6 June, 2016 | 0

    “He’s decent.” That may be the most memorable line from the recent batch of Oscar-nominated films. It’s how Eilis (Saorise Ronan), the lead character in Brooklyn, describes her new American boyfriend, Tony (Emory Cohen), to her sister, Rose (Fiona Glascot), back home in Ireland.

    Brooklyn takes place in two worlds, the close community of an Irish village and the eponymous New York borough in the early 1950s. These worlds share a common understanding of morality; a clear line between the “fellas” that young women like Eilis would describe as “decent” and others who wouldn’t quality.

    Brooklyn might be described as a quiet film, as there are no scenes of violence and hardly a raised voice. Yet the picture carries with it a penetrating sense of risk at every turn.

    Much of this risk is generated by Eilis’s situation as an immigrant. A priest from the old country has kindly provided her with a job and the ability to attend Night College, where she undertakes studies to qualify as an accountant. Like every immigrant she aspires to make a success in her new country while being desperately homesick. At the worst times her heartache is so great that she dissolves in tears, if in the most dignified and restrained way.

    So, we naturally root and worry for Eilis, particularly as Soarise Ronan delivers an utterly transporting performance. (Brie Larson was great in Room, but I would have given the Oscar to Ronan.) Eilis’s heartfelt ambivalence gains in intensity when a death in the family has her return to Ireland, where the prospect of a full life with a job and a young man unexpectedly opens. Her new suitor, Jim Farrell (Domhnall Gleeson), is by her reckoning, “smart and civilized and charming” and “a gentleman.”

    There’s something even deeper or more intensely felt in Brooklyn than an immigrant’s divided loyalties; something more universal as well that provides a fuller accounting for what’s at risk.

    Eilis knows that the choice she makes in marrying will determine so much about the rest of her life. So it’s vital to choose a fella who is decent; who treats her with all the dignity that’s due another human being; who does not exploit her for his own selfish ends, whether sexual or otherwise.

    She insists that her American boyfriend, Tony—who is immediately and utterly smitten with her—take his time in courting her. Their romance and the one that follows with Jim in Ireland reminds us both of the prudence and romantic power of 1950s courtship. We have the pleasure of witnessing how courtesy, respect, and discretion—really, all the virtues great and small—allow for each of the young peoples’ humanity to flourish. The morality by which they live directs their behavior, giving each the opportunity to think through their choices and make them considered ones.

    Or almost.

    Knowing that Eilis is returning to Ireland to visit her mother—and suspecting that her homeland may recall her permanently—Tony proposes that Eilis and he secretly elope to the registrar’s office before she goes. His rush frightens us, and for good reason, as it turns out, when Eilis considers staying in Ireland with Jim.

    There’s something right about the rushed decision to marry, too, though—or, at least, it conveys an undeniable aspect of life. Decisions, especially important decisions like the choice of a mate, force upon us the naked experience of our freedom. Choices finally belong purely to the will.

    “I want to do this.” So we take the plunge.

    Which isn’t to say there isn’t a difference between wise choices and foolish ones, only that there’s no eliminating the unknown and the glorious if terrifying experience of choosing as best we can.

    Tony begins speaking early on about “their children;” he hopes they won’t be Yankee fans, as he loves his Brooklyn bums, the Dodgers. Eilis cues him that it’s a little too early to be speaking about children, but not because there’s any doubt in her mind that children come with marriage. After Tony’s proposal they both speculate happily as to whether they will ever tell their children the story of their secret wedding.

    Their common expectation that marriage naturally entails children belongs to that common morality that binds the two worlds. It weighs heavily among Eilis’s considerations as she seeks out someone to marry. For Eilis, this is only realistic.

    Many now believe that we’ve replaced the code of behavior on display in Brooklyn with more flexible standards by virtue of reproductive technology. Youthful sexuality can now flourish divorced from all those weighty decisions–or so some would have it.

    Why then do we feel that the world of Brooklyn is still more like our own than not? Or that we might prefer our world to be more like the film’s?

    We still find ourselves at intense risk when choosing a mate or entering into a relationship. Our choices become part of our fate. That the prevailing moral code in Brooklyn has virtually vanished and been replaced by a menu of options hasn’t made–to judge by peoples’ levels of satisfaction in life–for much comfort.

    I think we still want to find someone “decent.” I wonder if doing so hasn’t become harder.

    No tags.

    Related Post

    • Jon Hamm Teases Details About His New Character in the Much Anticipated Sequel Top Gun: Maverick

      By Amber Hadley | Comments are Closed

      Jon Hamm gives us an inside look at his new character Vice Admiral Cyclone in the new Top Gun movie. He talks of ‘friction’ between his character and Tom Cruise’s character, Maverick.

    • Eddie Vedder Gave Bradley Cooper Advice for ‘A Star is Born’

      By John Dennis | Comments are Closed

      What better way is there to learn how to play a convincing rockstar on the big screen than to get pointers from the real thing? It was recently revealed on The Howard Stern Show that Bradley Cooper did just that when preparing to play Jackson Maine, the grizzled, deteriorating foil to Lady Gaga’s Ally Maine, in 2018’s A Star is Born.

    • Remembering Sean Connery as Bond, James Bond

      By John Dennis | Comments are Closed

      On October 31st, the entertainment world lost yet another icon. Sean Connery, Academy Award winning actor, passed away at the age of 90. Connery leaves behind a staggering cinematic legacy spanning decades and featuring a slew of timeless roles — but there’s one franchise in particular that he undoubtedly left his mark on.

    • Bette Midler Teases More Details About The Highly Anticipated Hocus Pocus Sequel

      By Chloe Paglia | Comments are Closed

      Halloween just passed and reminded us all, as it has every year since 1993, that Hocus Pocus is arguably one of the best Halloween movies ever. And just like Thanksgiving dinner, I personally would argueRead more

    • “Borat Subsequent Moviefilm,” Sacha Baron Cohen Follows Up First ‘Great Success’

      By John Dennis | Comments are Closed

      One of the ways Webster’s dictionary defines a troll is “a person who intentionally antagonizes others online by posting inflammatory, irrelevant, or offensive comments or other disruptive content,” and whereas Sacha Baron Cohen, the comedicRead more

    • Sign up for our Daily Digest, where we deliver the top headlines in music and exclusive SCENES Live Sessions details straight to your inbox!

    Download Sessions and Buy Merch

    • George Shingleton on SCENES Live Sessions $2.99
    • Brennley Brown on SCENES Live Sessions $2.99
    • Brett Kissel on SCENES Live Sessions $2.99
    • The Joy Reunion on SCENES Live Sessions $2.99
    • Penny Betts on SCENES Live Sessions $2.99
    • Media Kit
    • Privacy Policy
    © 2022 | All Rights Reserved
    • Home
    • Country
    • Pop
    • Rock
    • Americana
    • R&B
    • Culture
    • Premium
    • About
    • Contact
      • Music Submissions
      • Advertising
        • Media Kit
      • Customer Support
    • Shop
    SCENES
      0 items