SCENESSCENESSCENESSCENES
    0
  •   was successfully added to your cart.
  • Home
  • Country
  • Pop
  • Rock
  • Americana
  • R&B
  • Culture
  • Premium
  • About
  • Contact
    • Music Submissions
    • Advertising
      • Media Kit
    • Customer Support
  • Shop

Harry Potter Is Not Childish

    Home The New Copernicans Harry Potter Is Not Childish
    Harry Potter is Not Childish

    Harry Potter Is Not Childish

    By John Seel | The New Copernicans | 1 comment | 6 July, 2017 | 0

    In a recent blog, “Living with Enchantment,” I wrote of New Copernicans, “We are moderns that believe in magic.” I cited Doctor Strange, Elizabeth Gilbert, and yes, Harry Potter. So I was intrigued to read Gracy Olmstead’s article in The Federalist, “Harry Potter Offered Millennials Enchantment in a Disenchanted World.” However, on closer reading my stomach turned sour.

    Gracy makes the correct observation quoting Lara Prendergast in The Spectator, “Harry Potter may be a literary fantasy but for many it is also a substitute religion in a secular age.” But then she turns snarky suggesting that this “reflects a spiritual vacuum experienced” by millennials. She continues, “Many millennials dwell in a secularized world, one increasingly shed of magic and enchantment. The Western world is increasingly agnostic, while the millennial generation itself is populated with so-called “nones”—religiously unaffiliated, and uninterested in organized religion.”

    Actually, the evidence points in exactly the opposite direction. New Copernicans are not disenchanted secularists, but enchanted secularists. This is an option she completely misses in her binary view of the universe. The reason Harry Potter resonates so deeply is that New Copernicans do not embrace the closed immanent perspective of New Atheists, but an open immanent one that is haunted by the possibility and potential of a larger world of meaning and spirits. Secular, yes. Magic, yes.

    Not only does Olmstead confuse frames, she blurs the line between culture and politics. Granted that she is writing for a conservative political publication, and as such she has to take her unfortunate stabs at Rowling’s progressive views on the LGBT community, suggesting that the Potterverse morphs into a progressive tale of good and evil: “Hogwarts would have been a ‘safe place’ for LGBT students.”

    And then to put the cherry on her snarky sundae, she has to put down the magical aspirations of Harry Potter readers or viewers as childish. Quoting Prendergast she writes, “For all the joy that Harry Potter brings to its millions of readers, the world cannot be sorted by a magical hat.” Gracy concludes, “Millennials are just doing what most religious people do when they cite a religious text in response to a political problem.” So politics trumps religion, and technical rationalism the imagination.

    Who’s being secular now?

    Rather than warning that “children’s books can’t be our Bibles,” perhaps she should consider more deeply Jesus’ admonition, “I tell you the truth, unless you change and become like little children, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven” (Matthew 18:3). Her initial insight does not make up for the usual litany of snarky millennial putdowns. Get the frame wrong and everything goes off the rails. New Copernicans know better. The metaphor of the Potterverse points not to childish fairy tales but to adult realities. Narnia was not a childish world in C.S. Lewis’ mind. It was a truer and deeper reality. The fiction only pointed toward a deeper consciousness.

    C.S. Lewis, Harry Potter, millennials, Narnia, The New Copernicans

    Related Post

    • #MeToo Plus #NeverAgain: A Red Line Has Been Crossed

      By John Seel | Comments are Closed

      Young people are changing society with hashtag activism.

    • Reality’s Push Back: PTSD and ‘Thank You for Your Service’

      By John Seel | Comments are Closed

      Reality is pushing back and we don’t like it. We like our wars quick, our victories decisive, and our soldiers John Wayne. That is not the reality of our contemporary nation or military. We needRead more

    • Millennials at Work

      Three Keys to Cultural Change and Why Millennials Will Lead

      By John Seel | Comments are Closed

      Culture change requires three things and millennials are poised to maximize them. The dynamics of cultural change are more like football than golf. Golf is a solitary sport where the individual is expected to beRead more

    • President Trump Tweeting

      Is There a Method to the Madness of Trump’s Tweets?

      By John Seel | Comments are Closed

      Trump is controversial. Trump’s Tweets are even more so—both to his supporters and his detractors. Perhaps we have been looking at them in the wrong way! Is there a method to his madness? Berkeley cognitiveRead more

    • Hanging of Catholic in "Gunpowder"

      A Misfire that Matters: Kit Harington’s ‘Gunpowder’

      By John Seel | Comments are Closed

      This is a British story exported to the U.S. Its resonance here will be very different from the U.K. where it played last October on BBC. The Gunpowder Plot is celebrated annually in England as Guy Fawkes Day. It is the British equivalent of our 9/11. And like 9/11 it is seared into the British consciousness.

    • Tim Cleary July 7, 2017 at 8:41 pm

      Thankyou for this John. A true word!

    • Sign up for our Daily Digest, where we deliver the top headlines in music and exclusive SCENES Live Sessions details straight to your inbox!

    Download Sessions and Buy Merch

    • Kendall Beard on SCENES Live Sessions Kendall Beard on SCENES Live Sessions $2.99
    • Zach and Maggie on SCENES Live Sessions Zach and Maggie on SCENES Live Sessions $2.99
    • Lindsay Foote and Liv on SCENES Live Sessions Lindsay Foote and Liv on SCENES Live Sessions $2.99
    • Whitacre on SCENES Live Sessions Whitacre on SCENES Live Sessions $2.99
    • Billy Raffoul on SCENES Live Sessions Billy Raffoul on SCENES Live Sessions $2.99
    • Media Kit
    • Privacy Policy
    © 2022 | All Rights Reserved
    • Home
    • Country
    • Pop
    • Rock
    • Americana
    • R&B
    • Culture
    • Premium
    • About
    • Contact
      • Music Submissions
      • Advertising
        • Media Kit
      • Customer Support
    • Shop
    SCENES
      0 items